A commercial tenant that agrees to take premises “as is” and comply with the law at its own expense may be stuck with the lease even when the city shuts down its use. That is the lesson of Trucks Rx, Inc v Padilla Investments, LLC, an unpublished Court of Appeals opinion issued October 21, 2026 (Docket No. 375909).
The timing is notable. The same day, another panel decided Skidmore v Hayashi, voiding a residential lease because the landlords lacked a rental certificate. In my article on Skidmore, I asked what its reasoning might mean for commercial leases. Trucks Rx does not answer that question, but it shows how the same kind of dispute can play out very differently.
The Facts
In February 2022, two companies signed a three-year lease of a former hardware store in Detroit, intending to sell tires there. Their owners personally guaranteed the lease. The lease limited the use to selling new vehicle tires unless the landlord consented otherwise in writing. The tenants agreed to comply with all laws and ordinances, to assume any resulting financial responsibility, and to accept the premises “as is.”
The city soon stepped in:
- April 2022: The city issued the landlord a correction order listing code or zoning violations.
- June 2022: An emergency correction order cited illegal use because no permit had been issued for it. The city ordered the use discontinued and required the landlord to correct the deficiencies and obtain a certificate of compliance.
- July 2022: The tenants stopped paying rent.
- August 2022: Another order said the building was operating illegally as a major auto repair, semi-truck storage, terminal, and dispatch operation, when its only legal use was retail.
- September 2022: The tenants abandoned the premises.
- November 2022: The landlord obtained a certificate of compliance for a retail or wholesale store.
The chief problem was the lack of an automatic sprinkler system, which was required to store tires on the property. The tenants’ side estimated the system would cost more than $60,000 and take four to six months to install. The parties stipulated that they had not discussed fire suppression before signing. The landlord’s principal offered to attend a meeting with city officials, but the tenants’ side did not show up.
The Decision
The landlord won at arbitration, and the Court of Appeals affirmed the circuit court’s judgment confirming the award. The arbitrator found that the lease was unambiguous and required the tenants, not the landlord, to do what was necessary to operate their business. He rejected the argument that the lease was void or unenforceable and awarded $411,131.50 plus interest, including against the guarantors.
The panel rejected each of the challenges raised on appeal:
- Impossibility or impracticability. The lease put compliance on the tenants at their own expense, and they accepted the premises “as is.” The Court also agreed that the tenants were better positioned to know what their business legally required.
- Mutual mistake. The Court distinguished the barren-cow case, Sherwood v Walker, 66 Mich 568 (1887). The need for a fire suppression system did not change the whole substance of the agreement, because the tenants had to make the premises suitable for their business if necessary.
- Assumption of risk. The Court would not review the arbitrator’s allocation of risk. It added that Lenawee Co Bd of Health v Messerly, 417 Mich 17 (1982), did not help the appellants, because the “as is” clause in that case also placed the risk on the buyers.
The Court concluded that the arbitrator neither exceeded his authority nor made an error of law apparent on the face of the award.
What the Case Does Not Decide
Trucks Rx is helpful to commercial landlords, but it has real limits:
- It is unpublished. The opinion does not bind trial courts. Skidmore, which is published, does.
- It reviews an arbitration award. Courts may not review an arbitrator’s fact findings or mental process, and only a substantial legal error apparent on the face of the award will do. The result might not carry over to a case tried in court.
- It does not analyze illegality. The arbitrator rejected a void-or-unenforceable defense, but the opinion addresses impossibility, mutual mistake, and assumption of risk. It does not cite Skidmore or Stokes, or ask whether any illegality was central to the lease.
Reading Skidmore and Trucks Rx Together
The two opinions can be reconciled, though neither court tried to do so.
| Skidmore | Trucks Rx | |
|---|---|---|
| Lease | Residential | Commercial |
| Status | Published | Unpublished |
| Posture | Summary disposition, reviewed de novo | Limited review of an arbitration award |
| Legal problem | Ordinance barred renting and occupying without a certificate | City found no permit for the use; a sprinkler system was required to store tires |
| Lease terms discussed | No compliance-allocation clause discussed | “As is” and tenant compliance clauses |
| Outcome | Lease void; landlords’ claim dismissed | Lease enforced; $411,131.50 plus interest |
In my view, the best way to harmonize them is this: in Skidmore, the ordinance prohibited the core performance of the lease. In Trucks Rx, the building had a lawful retail use, and the tenants had agreed to do what was needed to make their particular business compliant.
The tension does not disappear, however. The lease in Trucks Rx allowed only new tire sales. A tenant in that position can argue that the sole permitted use was unlawful from the first day, that the use was central to the lease, and that Skidmore therefore controls. The fact that Detroit directed its orders to the owner helps that argument. The landlord’s response is that a curable condition, assigned to the tenant by contract, is not illegality at the center of the bargain. Until a court addresses that question, commercial landlords and tenants should treat it as open.
What Commercial Landlords Should Do
- Keep clear “as is,” inspection, and tenant-compliance clauses in your leases, and specify who must obtain permits and perform required work.
- Verify the lawful use of the premises before signing, including whether any certificate of occupancy or compliance is needed.
- Define permitted uses broadly enough to include clearly lawful ones. A single narrow use gives the tenant a stronger Skidmore argument if that use turns out to be unlawful.
- Do not treat these clauses as a cure-all. If the illegality is central under Stokes, a risk-allocation clause may fall with the rest of the lease.
What Commercial Tenants Should Do
- Before signing, find out what zoning, building, and fire codes require for your exact use, including storage.
- Price any required work and allow for the downtime. Here, the estimate was more than $60,000 and four to six months.
- If approvals or improvements are uncertain, negotiate a contingency, rent abatement, or termination right.
- Do not assume that a surprise code requirement will excuse performance. Under an “as is” and compliance clause, the risk may already be yours.
- If you are guaranteeing the lease, read those clauses as if the debt were your own. It may become your own.
I will be watching to see whether a Michigan appellate court addresses Skidmore in a commercial lease dispute. In the meantime, landlords and tenants with questions about a lease are welcome to contact my office.
The Trucks Rx opinion is available here. The Skidmore opinion is available here.
This post is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. — Donald H. Passenger, Passenger Law PLLC, Grand Rapids, Michigan.