On October 21, 2026, the Michigan Court of Appeals issued a published opinion in Skidmore v Hayashi (Docket Nos. 371345, 371349) that every landlord, residential or commercial, should know about. The Court held that a residential lease was void from the outset because the landlords never obtained the rental certificate of compliance required by their township’s ordinance. Because the opinion is published, it is binding on Michigan trial courts. It will be interesting to see whether the case goes to the Michigan Supreme Court, for the reasons discussed below.
Update: On the same day Skidmore was issued, a different Court of Appeals panel enforced a commercial lease despite a city order stopping the tenants’ use of the premises. I discuss Trucks Rx, Inc v Padilla Investments, LLC in a separate article.
It raises an interesting point, can you, at least in a commercial setting avoid the trap of voidness found in Skidmore and explained below? Or, it it an entirely different thing?The Facts
So, back to Skidmore where a West Bloomfield Township ordinance prohibits owners from renting, and anyone from occupying, a residential unit without a certificate of compliance. The landlords admitted they never had one. After a dispute over roof leaks and mold, the tenant left, and the landlords sued for roughly $25,000 in back rent and late fees.
The Holding
The Court of Appeals held the lease void ab initio. Applying the long-standing rule that courts will not enforce a contract whose illegality is central to the parties’ agreement (Stokes v Millen Roofing Co, 466 Mich 660 (2002)), the Court reasoned that renting and occupying the unit was the very purpose of the lease, and both were prohibited without the certificate. The consequences were significant:
- The landlords’ claim for back rent and late fees was dismissed.
- The tenant’s own breach-of-contract claim also failed, since there was no valid contract.
- The tenant’s unjust-enrichment and disgorgement claims were reinstated, opening the door to recovery of rent he had already paid.
- The tenant could not sue for conversion of his security deposit or under the Truth in Renting Act, because both depend on a valid lease, but the deposit can be considered as part of his unjust-enrichment claim. His conversion claim for other personal property was reinstated.
The trial court had relied on McMillan v Douglas, 322 Mich App 354 (2017), which held that this type of ordinance gives tenants no private right of action. The Court of Appeals rejected that approach. In its view, the common-law rule against enforcing illegal contracts exists independently of whatever remedies the ordinance itself provides. It distinguished McMillan as a suit brought under the ordinance to recover rent, rather than a contract-law challenge to the validity of the lease.
Why This Case Could Be Headed to the Supreme Court
Several features of the opinion make it a candidate for an application for leave to appeal:
- Tension with McMillan. McMillan took a narrow view of what a tenant can do when a landlord lacks a rental certificate. Skidmore reaches a very different practical result through contract law. The distinction the Court drew between the two cases is a fine one, and the Supreme Court may want to reconcile them.
- A minor violation, a total forfeiture. The underlying violation was a municipal civil infraction carrying a modest fine. The Court did not ask whether the township intended violations to void leases, or weigh the seriousness of the violation against the forfeiture of an entire rental relationship.
- Restitution for a party who also violated the ordinance. The Court said the tenant’s occupancy violated the ordinance too. Yet he may recover rent he paid for premises he actually lived in. That is an aggressive outcome under traditional principles that courts leave parties to an illegal bargain where they find them.
- Potential reach beyond residential leases. The holding rests on general contract law, not on residential landlord-tenant statutes. How far it reaches into commercial leasing is the subject of the next section.
What About Commercial Leases?
Nothing in the Skidmore rule is limited to residential leases, but the result in a commercial case will depend on what the particular law prohibits. Commercial certificate-of-occupancy requirements, and leases for uses that zoning ordinances prohibit, fit much of the same reasoning. The West Bloomfield ordinance, however, directly barred renting and occupying the unit. The opinion also does not discuss any lease clause allocating compliance responsibility.
I expect three questions to matter in a commercial dispute:
- What exactly is prohibited? An ordinance barring occupancy looks different from a requirement that attaches only to a particular use or building condition.
- Was a lawful use available? A lease limited to one unlawful use presents a harder case for the landlord than a lease that also allows lawful uses.
- Could the defect be cured, and who agreed to cure it? A lease requiring the tenant to make the premises compliant may support an argument that the illegality is not central to the agreement.
Trucks Rx offers an early look at the commercial setting. There, the Court of Appeals upheld an arbitration award enforcing a commercial lease where the tenants had accepted the premises “as is” and agreed to comply with the law at their own expense. That opinion is unpublished, arises from limited review of an arbitration award, and does not apply the Stokes test. It therefore does not resolve how far Skidmore reaches, but it shows the argument a commercial landlord will make.
What Landlords Should Do Now
Unless and until the Supreme Court acts, Skidmore is the law. Landlords should consider the following:
- Confirm that every required rental certificate or certificate of occupancy is in place, and current, before a tenant takes possession.
- In commercial leases, define permitted uses broadly enough to include clearly lawful ones, and include a strong severability clause.
- Use clear “as is” and compliance-with-laws clauses in commercial leases. They carried real weight in Trucks Rx, but do not assume they will save the lease. If the illegality is central under Stokes, the risk-allocation clause may fall with the rest of the contract.
- Be aware that a guaranty of a void lease obligation may itself be unenforceable. If the lease stands, the guaranty can be fully enforced, as the guarantors in Trucks Rx learned.
- In collection litigation, plead an alternative claim for unjust enrichment or use and occupancy.
I will be watching to see whether an application for leave is filed and how the Supreme Court responds. In the meantime, landlords with questions about their leases or compliance status are welcome to contact my office.
The Skidmore opinion is available here.
This post is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. — Donald H. Passenger, Passenger Law PLLC, Grand Rapids, Michigan.
One response to “Skidmore v Hayashi: A Lease Voided Over a Missing Rental Certificate — Broader implications including unapproved lawful uses in commercial leases?”
[…] timing is notable. The same day, another panel decided Skidmore v Hayashi, voiding a residential lease because the landlords lacked a rental certificate. In my article on […]