Fighting Over Earnest Money in Michigan Real Estate: When Is It Worth It?


When a real estate deal falls apart, the fight often comes down to the earnest money deposit. The buyer wants it back; the seller believes it has been earned. Both sides usually feel strongly that they are right. But being right and coming out ahead are two different things, and in an earnest money dispute, the cost of proving you are right can easily exceed the amount at stake.

This post walks through the questions I ask when someone comes to me with a deposit dispute, and the realistic options for resolving one.

First Question: Is the Deal Actually Dead?

Before anyone fights over the deposit, it is worth confirming that there is a deposit to fight over. People often assume a deal is terminated because one side has walked away or stopped responding. Under the purchase agreement, that may not be true.

  • Was a contingency actually not satisfied, or did the deadline pass in a way the agreement treats as a waiver?
  • Did the party who claims to have terminated give the written notice the agreement requires, on time?
  • Is the other side’s refusal to close a breach that gives you a choice of remedies, rather than an end to the contract?

The answers matter because real estate is treated as unique, and a court may order a party to complete the sale through an action for specific performance. A buyer who still wants the property may be better served by enforcing the agreement than by asking for the deposit back. A seller facing a buyer who wants out may have more than the deposit at stake. And a party who demands its deposit back may, in doing so, be treated as having abandoned the deal, giving up rights it did not know it had.

Richardson v Wright, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued January 25, 2024 (Docket Nos. 361839, 361841, 362999), illustrates the choice. The buyer had paid a $7,500 deposit on a $449,000 house. When the appraisal came in low, the purchase agreement adjusted the price, and the seller tried to back out. The agreement gave the buyer, on seller default, the option to enforce the contract or take back the entire deposit. The buyer chose to enforce it, and the trial court ordered the sale to close at the adjusted price. The Court of Appeals affirmed, noting that contracts for the sale of land are generally subject to specific performance. In re Egbert R Smith Trust, 480 Mich 19, 26 (2008). A buyer who had simply asked for the $7,500 back would have walked away from the house.

Sorting this out requires reading the purchase agreement as a whole: the contingencies, the notice requirements, the deposit clause, and the default provisions together. That analysis is usually worth an hour or two of a lawyer’s time, even when the deposit itself is modest. It is far cheaper than discovering later that you walked away from a deal you could have enforced, or gave up a deposit you were entitled to keep.

The Economics of a Deposit Dispute

If the deal really is over, the next question is a practical one: what will it cost to get the money? It is often difficult to justify hiring a lawyer to litigate an earnest money dispute, because the return on investment is poor. Many residential deposits are a few thousand dollars. A contested lawsuit, even a simple one, frequently costs $5,000 to $10,000 or more in attorney fees by the time it is resolved. A party can win the case and still lose money.

Richardson again makes the point. The buyer’s attorney fees through the summary disposition stage came to roughly $27,000, more than three times the $7,500 deposit. The buyer recovered those fees only because the court found the seller’s defenses frivolous and awarded sanctions, and even then the fee award was sent back to the trial court for a further explanation of the hours billed. Most deposit disputes will not involve frivolous defenses, and without a fee-shifting provision, each side pays its own lawyer.

It is also worth confirming that the money is actually there. In Claire-Ann Co v Christenson & Christenson, Inc, 223 Mich App 25 (1997), the buyers’ $25,000 earnest money check bounced and the buyers never appeared for closing. The seller sued the listing broker, which had acknowledged receiving the deposit in writing, but the Court of Appeals reversed a judgment for the seller. It held that the broker-escrow provisions of the Occupational Code did not give the seller a private cause of action, and that a written acknowledgment of a deposit creates only a rebuttable presumption that the money was actually received. The seller litigated through an appeal over a deposit that never existed.

Doesn’t the Purchase Agreement Shift the Fees?

Sometimes. The West Michigan Regional Purchase Agreement, the form used by the Greater Regional Alliance of REALTORS® (GRAR) in the Grand Rapids area, provides that in litigation over the deposit, the non-prevailing party reimburses the other for reasonable attorney fees and expenses. That is a meaningful protection, and it changes the calculation. But it has limits:

  • “Reasonable” is decided by the court. The fees awarded may be less than the fees actually incurred.
  • An award is not a payment. A judgment for fees is only as good as the losing party’s ability and willingness to pay it.
  • Fee-shifting cuts both ways. A party that is confident but wrong may end up paying both sides’ lawyers.
  • Interpleader costs erode the deposit. The same form allows the broker holding the deposit to interplead it, that is, to deposit it with the court and let the court decide who gets it, and provides for the broker’s attorney fees in that action. As a practical matter, those costs are often satisfied from the funds on deposit, leaving the winning party to seek reimbursement from the losing party. The longer the fight, the smaller the pot.

The GRAR form also contains a useful tool for avoiding all of this: the broker may notify the parties of its intended disposition of the deposit, and a party that does not object in writing within 15 days is deemed to agree. If you receive such a notice, do not ignore it. Silence is an answer.

Other forms handle fees differently, and some say nothing at all about deposit disputes. Check your own agreement.

Your Realistic Options

1. A Well-Asserted Position at the Outset

Many deposit disputes are resolved on the front end, before anyone files anything. A letter from a lawyer that lays out the relevant contract provisions, explains why the deposit belongs to the client, and points out the fee-shifting and interpleader consequences of a fight often prompts the other side, and the broker holding the funds, to look at the agreement more carefully. The cost is a fraction of litigation, and it frequently ends the matter. Even when it does not, it frames the dispute and sets up whatever comes next.

2. Small Claims Court

For many deposits, small claims court is the most sensible forum. In Michigan, the small claims division of the district court can hear most civil disputes where the amount in controversy is $7,000 or less. MCL 600.8401(e). A claim worth more can still be filed there, but the court cannot award more than $7,000. Filing fees are modest, the process is informal, and a case is typically heard by a judge or magistrate within a few months.

There are trade-offs. Unless the case is removed, the parties to a small claims action waive the right to counsel, the right to a jury, the right to recover more than $7,000, and any right of appeal, except that a magistrate’s decision may be appealed to a district judge. MCL 600.8412; MCL 600.8427. And small claims can only award money. It cannot order a sale to close, so it is not the place for a party seeking specific performance.

No discovery. Formal discovery (interrogatories, document requests, depositions) is not permitted in small claims. MCR 2.301(A)(3). That is both a disadvantage and an advantage. You cannot force the other side to produce its emails, texts, or file before the hearing, so you must win with the evidence you already have. But neither side can run up the cost of the case with discovery, which is a large part of why small claims is fast and inexpensive. Removal does not automatically change this: in the district court’s general civil division, discovery before judgment is allowed only by leave of court or stipulation of the parties. MCR 2.301(A)(2). Because you may have to prove your case with only your own records, it is all the more important to preserve them from the start.

Removal, and why it can work in your favor. Before the trial begins, either party may remove the case to the district court’s general civil division, where lawyers may participate. MCL 600.8408(4). Once a case is removed, either party may amend its pleadings to increase the amount claimed above the small claims limit, upon paying the difference in the filing fee. MCL 600.8425(2). So if what you are owed exceeds $7,000 (the deposit plus other damages, for example), say so in your claim, describing the full amount, even though you can recover no more than $7,000 while the case stays in small claims. MCL 600.8425(1). A defendant who knows that removal reopens the full claim has a reason to think twice before removing.

That disincentive is stronger still when the defendant is a corporation or an LLC. In small claims, a business may appear through an officer or employee with personal knowledge of the facts. MCL 600.8408(2). Outside small claims, however, a corporation may appear in court only through a licensed attorney. Detroit Bar Ass’n v Union Guardian Trust Co, 282 Mich 707 (1938); Peters Production, Inc v Desnick Broadcasting Co, 171 Mich App 283 (1988). A business that removes the case therefore takes on the cost of hiring counsel, and faces a larger claim. That combination often encourages a business to resolve the matter rather than fight it.

Once you start in small claims, the no-lawyer rule follows the case. A party that does not remove the case waives the right to counsel at every stage, including post-judgment collection proceedings in the small claims division. In re Goehring, 184 Mich App 360, 363-364 (1990); see also MJI, District Court Magistrate Manual, ch 7. A party who expects to need a lawyer later, to collect a judgment or otherwise, should weigh that before the hearing begins, because the decision to stay in small claims cannot be undone afterward.

Tell your story in the affidavit. Small claims hearings are informal, and the judge or magistrate decides according to substantive law but without the formal rules of procedure and evidence. MCL 600.8411(2). Hearings also move quickly. Make the Affidavit and Claim detailed enough that the judge or magistrate can understand the dispute before you say a word. Identify the purchase agreement, the contingency or default at issue, the key dates and notices, who holds the deposit, and why it belongs to you. If the form does not have enough room, attach a short, organized statement along with the key documents (the purchase agreement, any addenda, and the termination or demand correspondence). Then bring copies of everything to the hearing, as the notice of hearing requires. MCL 600.8404(1)(b).

Even though a lawyer cannot appear with you in small claims, an hour of advice beforehand on which contract provisions matter, how to frame the affidavit, and whether removal is likely can make a real difference. Michigan Legal Help has a good overview of the small claims process, including do-it-yourself forms: An Overview of Small Claims Court.

3. Compromise

Sometimes the best answer is to split the difference. A compromise has real value: it is certain, it is immediate, and it frees both parties to move on, the seller to relist and the buyer to find another property. When the deposit is modest, the merits are genuinely debatable, and the alternative is months of litigation that will consume much of the money in dispute, a negotiated release is often the most rational outcome. It is not a sign of weakness to recognize when the fight costs more than it is worth.

A Practical Checklist

  1. Determine whether the deal is truly terminated, or whether it can or should be enforced through specific performance.
  2. Read the deposit, contingency, notice, default, and attorney fee provisions of your agreement together.
  3. Respond in writing, and on time, to any notice from the broker or the other party.
  4. Preserve every document and communication: the purchase agreement and addenda, emails, text messages, voicemails, call logs, photographs, and inspection, appraisal, and lender correspondence. Save electronic items now. Phone call logs in particular are often overwritten after a short time and can be difficult to recover later. Consider sending the other side a litigation hold notice asking them to preserve their information too. (Download a sample litigation hold notice below.)
  5. Compare the amount at stake to the realistic cost of recovering it, including interpleader costs and the risk of paying the other side’s fees.
  6. Consider a lawyer’s letter first, small claims if the amount fits, and compromise if the economics point that way.
  7. If you file in small claims, state the full amount you are owed, make the affidavit detailed (with attachments if needed), and decide before the hearing starts whether you want the case to stay there.

Sample Litigation Hold Notice

A litigation hold notice is a letter asking the other side to preserve all documents and electronic information relating to the dispute, including emails, texts, call logs, voicemails, and photographs, and to turn off any automatic deletion settings. It puts them on notice that evidence matters, which can be important if relevant information later turns up missing. Because small claims has no formal discovery, a hold notice is also a practical way to keep the other side’s records intact in case the dispute ends up in the general civil division, where discovery may be allowed. The sample below is written for an earnest money dispute. Fill in the bracketed items, remove anything that does not fit, and send it in a way you can prove, such as email plus certified mail.

If you are facing a dispute over an earnest money deposit, or are unsure whether your deal is really over, please contact my office. An hour or two at the outset can save a great deal of time and money later.

Sources


This post is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. — Donald H. Passenger, Passenger Law PLLC, Grand Rapids, Michigan.