HCB Properties v Island Investments: Contingencies interpreted in context of whole agreement and where does my earnest money go when the deal breaks?


Financing contingencies are among the most common clauses in commercial and residential purchase agreements, and among the most loosely drafted. A recent Michigan Court of Appeals decision, HCB Properties, LLC v Island Investments Inc, unpublished per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals, issued October 19, 2026 (Docket No. 371730), shows what can happen when a financing contingency leaves out a key term: the loan amount. The result was a $250,000 lesson for the seller.

The Facts

The purchase agreement set the purchase price, plus a buyer’s premium, at $2,600,000. The buyer paid two escrow deposits totaling $250,000. The agreement made the sale contingent upon “financing approval for Buyer, at an interest rate not to exceed 8%.” It did not state a loan amount.

The buyer obtained approval for a loan of $1,622,727 at 7.45%, well short of the amount needed to close. The deal fell through, and the parties fought over the deposits. The seller argued that the only condition in the contingency was the 8% rate cap, so the buyer’s approval at 7.45% satisfied it and the deposits were forfeited.

The Holding

The Court of Appeals affirmed summary disposition for the buyer, who was entitled to the return of both deposits. The Court described the seller’s reading of the contingency as “myopic.” Under settled Michigan law, a contract term is read in the context of the agreement as a whole, not in isolation. Tenneco Inc v Amerisure Mut Ins Co, 281 Mich App 429, 462 (2008).

Read together with the earlier sentences of the same paragraph, which fixed the price at $2,600,000, “financing approval” meant approval for the full amount needed to close. The seller pointed out that the buyer had planned to put in $600,000 of its own money, but the Court found that irrelevant: the agreement said nothing about how the purchase price would be financed.

The Court also rejected the seller’s alternative argument. The second deposit was triggered by the buyer’s “financing preapproval.” The seller contended that by paying that deposit, the buyer had effectively waived the contingency. The Court disagreed: “preapproval” and “approval” are different things, and paying a deposit on preapproval did not waive the separate condition of approval.

Drafting Lessons

The buyer won here, but only after litigating through the Court of Appeals. Both buyers and sellers can avoid that fight with a few drafting choices:

  • State the loan amount. Specify the amount (or loan-to-value ratio) the buyer must obtain. Do not leave it to a court to infer the amount from the price term.
  • Say what the buyer is contributing. If the buyer intends to fund part of the price with its own cash, and the seller is relying on that, put it in the contract.
  • Distinguish preapproval from approval. If different deposits are tied to different financing milestones, define each milestone, preapproval, approval, or a written loan commitment, precisely.
  • Address when deposits go hard. State expressly whether any deposit becomes nonrefundable on preapproval or another milestone, and whether paying it waives any contingency.

Thinking about fighting for your earnest money deposit (EMD), think again?

A Note on Unpublished Opinions

HCB Properties is unpublished, so it is not binding precedent. Under MCR 7.215(C)(1), however, it may be cited as persuasive authority, without attaching a copy, as long as the citation includes the docket number and date of decision. Its reasoning applies well-established contract-interpretation principles, and a trial court facing a similarly silent financing contingency may well find it persuasive.

If you are buying or selling property and have questions about your purchase agreement, please contact my office.

The opinion is available here.


This post is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. — Donald H. Passenger, Passenger Law PLLC, Grand Rapids, Michigan.

,